Cast Cinderella- Treasa Jacobs Melba- Emilie Myatt Goldilocks- Taylor Lott Red Riding Hood- Tricia Bartram Prince Charming- Brandon Barnes Jason- Scott Williams A.E. Rumplestiltskin- Jon Myatt Gretchen- Meghan Plahuta Aletta- Emily Schemrich Nanette-Sharon Hionides Magic Mirror/Narrator- Amanda Lloyd Pied Piper- Brian Miller Jack Caldwell- Joe Landrum